Scores do not fall in the second half of a competition, even though fatigue builds up

8 studies · 161 archers measured

ForContextAgainst20102015202020252017, context, n = 442024, for, n = 422021, for, n = 422026, for, n = 122026, for, n = 102026, context, n = 102020, context, n = 102009, context, n = 72024, context, n = 42022, for, n = 12022, context, n = 1
Each circle is a study: its position gives the year, its row whether it is for, against or context, its size how many participants it measured. Light circles are studies on other populations or without archers.

First and second half of the same round, in points per arrow, in four samples

Each pair of bars is the same round split in half. To put rounds of different length on the same scale we divided the points of each half by its arrows, 36 in the Turkish championship, 15 in the children, 30 in the Brazilian study and 36 at the Arab Championships, where the study does not say how many arrows each series has and we used the 36 set by the rules for the 70 m round; the whiskers are the study's standard deviation, divided in the same way. The rounds are not to be compared with one another, because distance, target face and bow all change: the second bar is read beside the first. None of the four studies tests the comparison between the two halves. The children have a fifteen-minute break halfway, the Brazilian archers ten minutes. Left out are the Malaysian case, a single archer, and the Turkish university group, which reports a test across the ten ends rather than the two halves. For the Arab Championships we worked out the mean of the 42 archers ourselves from the results table, so it has no whiskers: 21 archers drop, by 1 to 18 points, 18 go up and 3 match their first score, and of the four Egyptians only one drops, by 2 points. In the Brazilian study the same ten archers shoot twice, once after 45 minutes on social media and once after a video, and in the control condition the second half is 8.5 points lower over 30 arrows; across all twenty rounds the means are 218.8 and 216.0. The Turkish women's compound championship stays as context: the journal has questionable editorial standards and the figures do not add up, because the mean total of 574.09 is not the sum of the two halves and the means of the left-handed and right-handed archers do not give the overall one, so the two subgroups are left out. Data from: Gursoy et al. 2017, Bostanci et al. 2021, Ibrahim and Abdelgawad 2024 and Mafra et al. 2026.
The numbers in the figure
StudyGroupValue (points per arrow, mean)Intervaln
Gursoy et al. 2017, context: 44 women compound archers, Turkish national championship, two series of 36 arrows at 50 mFirst half7.9± 1.39 (mean ± standard deviation)44
Gursoy et al. 2017, context: 44 women compound archers, Turkish national championship, two series of 36 arrows at 50 mSecond half8.04± 1.46 (mean ± standard deviation)44
Bostanci et al. 2021, children aged 9 to 12, 30 arrows indoors at 18 mBoys, first 15 arrows7.35± 2.04 (mean ± standard deviation)31
Bostanci et al. 2021, children aged 9 to 12, 30 arrows indoors at 18 mBoys, second 157.43± 1.86 (mean ± standard deviation)31
Bostanci et al. 2021, children aged 9 to 12, 30 arrows indoors at 18 mGirls, first 15 arrows7.82± 1.18 (mean ± standard deviation)11
Bostanci et al. 2021, children aged 9 to 12, 30 arrows indoors at 18 mGirls, second 158.32± 0.94 (mean ± standard deviation)11
Ibrahim and Abdelgawad 2024, 2023 Arab Championships, 42 archers, two series at 70 m, means worked out by usFirst series8.0742
Ibrahim and Abdelgawad 2024, 2023 Arab Championships, 42 archers, two series at 70 m, means worked out by usSecond series8.1142
Mafra et al. 2026, 10 Brazilian archers, simulated 60-arrow indoor round at 18 mSocial media, first 30 arrows7.21± 1 (mean ± standard deviation)10
Mafra et al. 2026, 10 Brazilian archers, simulated 60-arrow indoor round at 18 mSocial media, second 307.3± 0.74 (mean ± standard deviation)10
Mafra et al. 2026, 10 Brazilian archers, simulated 60-arrow indoor round at 18 mControl, first 30 arrows7.37± 0.91 (mean ± standard deviation)10
Mafra et al. 2026, 10 Brazilian archers, simulated 60-arrow indoor round at 18 mControl, second 307.09± 1.32 (mean ± standard deviation)10

The studies that read the score inside a round point the same way: the second half is worth as much as the first, even as fatigue builds. In a Brazilian crossover on a simulated 60-arrow indoor round the first thirty arrows and the second thirty give close averages, 218.8 and 216.0 points, with no test on that comparison, while self-reported fatigue climbs from 2 to 3.8 and then to 5.8 out of ten; in a Turkish university group the score does not change from the first to the last of ten ends; in a Malaysian university archer electromyography shows fatigue building and the second half of seventy-two arrows closes on 318 points against 307, although within each set the lowest ends come towards the finish. The only real competition, the 2023 Arab Championships, sees half of the 42 archers score less in the second 70 m half, with drops of 1 to 18 points, and the other half not, in a reading of the results table without any statistical test; and in 42 children aged 9 to 12, with a fifteen-minute break halfway, the second part is no lower than the first. A Turkish women's compound championship gives the same picture, but in a journal with questionable editorial standards and with figures that do not add up, and it stays as context. The interesting part is that gap between what the archer feels and what goes on the scorecard. Where it breaks is the setting: the samples are small, nearly all the rounds are simulated and nearly every comparison of the two halves, the only real competition included, is read without a test, and nobody has followed a full day with qualification and matches; the only data on many hours of competition come from clay target shooting, where seven elite shooters do not fade over four rounds of fifty targets.

Also phrased as: "the last ends are the worst"; "scores fall at the end of a round"; "fatigue and scoring in competition"; "holding the score in the second half"; "scores drop in the second half"; "second distance of the ranking round"; "drop in the second half of the round"; "fatigue at the end of qualification"; "the last 36 arrows are the worst"; "second-half drop"; "score at the second distance"; "holding on to the last end"; "first and second half of a round"; "performance drop during competition"; "holding on to the end of a competition"; "fatigue over a competition day"; "performance after hours of shooting"

In practice

It is taken for granted on the range that the last ends are the worst, and endurance is trained precisely to hold the score until the end of the round.

Evidence

  • 2009
    Context Other sport Published later

    Seven elite double trap shooters, four rounds of 50 targets of about 16 minutes each, the third and fourth between four and five hours after the caffeine dose: no difference in score between rounds (p = 0.635 with 7 shooters, p = 0.436 with 5). It is another sport, with no bow to draw on each shot, and it measures performance over many hours, not the two halves of a round.

    Caffeine and performance in clay target shooting · Bianca Share, Nick Sanders, Justin Kemp

  • 2017
    Context Archers Published later

    44 women compound archers at the Turkish senior national championship, two series of 36 arrows at 50 m: on average 284.36 in the first half and 289.30 in the second. By group, the five left-handers stay level (334.80 and 335.80), while for the right-handers the study gives 227.90 and 283.33, figures that do not match their total of 561.72 or the overall mean. It points the claim's way, but with inconsistent figures and in a journal with questionable editorial standards: it stays as context.

    The Examination of the Relationship between Left-Handedness and Success in Elite Female Archers Questionable venue · Recep Gursoy, Suleyman Sahin, Mehmet Dalli, Kursat Hazar, Eser Aggon

  • 2020
    Context Archers Published later

    Ten Cypriot first-division archers in two simulated seventy-two-arrow rounds at seventy metres, at 36 to 37 degrees and with no food or drink from 8:20 to 10:50: self-reported fatigue rises over the round in both conditions, F(1,9) = 21.8, p = 0.001, and the total score does not differ between hydrated and dehydrated, 550 ± 63 against 562 ± 59. The score is reported only as a total, not half by half, so the gap between what is felt and what is scored cannot be read here.

    Effects of Dehydration on Archery Performance, Subjective Feelings and Heart Rate during a Competition Simulation · Alexandros Savvides, Christoforos D. Giannaki, Angelos Vlahoyiannis, Pinelopi S. Stavrinou, George Aphamis

  • 2021
    For Archers Published later

    42 recurve archers aged 9 to 12 (31 boys, 11 girls), 30 arrows at 18 m indoors with a 15-minute break after the first 15: boys 110.29 ± 30.58 then 111.42 ± 27.84; girls 117.27 ± 17.67 then 124.73 ± 14.14. The authors report no within-subject test on this comparison.

    The relationship between shooting performance and respiratory muscle strength in archers aged 9-12 · Ozgur Bostanci, Menderes Kabadayi, Muhammet Hakan Mayda, Ali Kerim Yilmaz, Coskun Yilmaz

  • 2022
    For Archers Published later

    One Malaysian university recurve archer, seventy-two arrows at thirty metres outdoors in two sets of six ends, in competition format: electromyography of the extensor digitorum on the bow arm and of the supraspinatus shows fatigue building towards the end, yet the second set closes on 318 points against 307 for the first, and analysis of variance finds no link between the fatigue of the two muscles and the score of each end (F from 0.65 to 1.93 against a critical F of 2.84). It is a single archer.

    Investigation of muscle fatigue of the archer’s during endurance shooting · Zul Amer Hamdan, Zulkifli Ahmad@Manap, Nasrul Hadi Johari

  • 2022
    Context Archers Published later

    Within each set, though, the lowest ends come in the last three: 47 out of 60 on the fifth end of the first set, 49 on the fourth of the second, and the second set opens on 55 and closes on 51. The authors read this as a possible sign of fatigue, with no test at all, and the difference is a few points in a single archer. Same study as the supporting item, so it counts once.

    Investigation of muscle fatigue of the archer’s during endurance shooting · Zul Amer Hamdan, Zulkifli Ahmad@Manap, Nasrul Hadi Johari

  • 2024
    For Archers Published later

    Results table from the 13th Arab Championships (Riyadh, 2023), 42 male archers from 14 nations, two 70 m halves: 21 of 42 (50%) score less in the second half than in the first, with drops of 1 to 18 points at both the top and the bottom of the rankings, while of the other 21, 18 improve (by up to 33 points) and 3 match their first score. It is a descriptive reading, with no statistical test, which the authors use to introduce an electromyography study of a single archer.

    Relationship between electromyography (EMG) as an indicator of muscle fatigue and archers’ accuracy · Essam Ibrahim, Mohamed Abdelgawad

  • 2024
    Context Archers Published later

    At the same event three of the four Egyptian national team archers improve in the second half (307 to 321, 314 to 320, 306 to 319) and only one drops, by 2 points, from 321 to 319. The authors infer that high-level archers resist fatigue better, but the basis is four athletes.

    Relationship between electromyography (EMG) as an indicator of muscle fatigue and archers’ accuracy · Essam Ibrahim, Mohamed Abdelgawad

  • 2026
    For Archers Published later

    10 Brazilian archers with competition experience, a simulated 60-arrow indoor round at 18 m in a randomised crossover: 216.3 ± 29.9 points on the first thirty arrows and 219 ± 22.3 on the second thirty in the social-media condition, 221.2 ± 27.2 and 212.7 ± 39.7 in the control condition, 218.8 and 216.0 across all twenty rounds. The comparison of the two halves is not tested: the study's p values (0.570 and 0.910) compare the two conditions within the same half. Over the same stretch, self-reported fatigue more than doubles.

    Efeitos do uso das redes sociais no desempenho do tiro com arco · Willyan Pagliuso Mafra, Otávio Joaquim Barrato de Azevedo, Loiane Cristina de Souza, Guilherme Torres Vilarino, Suzana Matheus Pereira

  • 2026
    For Archers Published later

    12 Turkish university recurve archers, 6.5 years of practice on average, 30 indoor arrows in two sessions 72 hours apart, one without and one with 200 mg of caffeine: the effect of the end on the score is not significant (F = 2.44 with the Greenhouse-Geisser correction) and nor is the interaction between condition and end (F = 0.53).

    An ergogenic approach to enhancing performance in archery: the acute effects of caffeine · Üstün Türker, Zeynep Hazal Ateş, Mümine Görgülü, Fatih Kıyıcı, Serdar Bayrakdaroğlu

  • 2026
    Context Archers Published later

    The same ten archers: fatigue on a visual analogue scale rises from 2.3 at the start to 3.8 at halfway and 5.8 at the end, with no statistical test reported. This measures the fatigue rather than the score, and it comes from the same sample as the supporting item, so it counts only once.

    Efeitos do uso das redes sociais no desempenho do tiro com arco · Willyan Pagliuso Mafra, Otávio Joaquim Barrato de Azevedo, Loiane Cristina de Souza, Guilherme Torres Vilarino, Suzana Matheus Pereira

Status history

  1. 1990 Not studied No study in the registry's bibliography has yet read a round's score half by half, or end by end, alongside the fatigue the archers report.
  2. 2009 Not studied The first data near the question come from another sport: seven elite double trap shooters do not fade over four rounds of fifty targets, the last two four to five hours after a caffeine dose. It measures performance over many hours, not the halves of a round, and clay shooting has no bow to draw on each shot: it stays as context, and in archers the question is still open.
  3. 2017 Not studied The first comparison of the two halves of a round in archers comes from a Turkish women's compound national championship: the 44 archers go on average from 284.4 points in the first half to 289.3 in the second. The study, however, appeared in a journal with questionable editorial standards and its figures do not add up, so it stays as context and does not decide the status: the question still has no answer that can be counted.
  4. 2020 Not studied The first figure close to the question measures fatigue but not the score half by half: in ten Cypriot archers shooting seventy-two arrows at seventy metres in 36 to 37 degrees, self-reported fatigue rises over the round, and the score is reported only as a total. Without the second half set beside the first, the question stays open.
  5. 2021 Reported The first data that can be counted arrive, in children: forty-two archers aged 9 to 12 shoot thirty arrows at 18 metres with a fifteen-minute break halfway, and the second part is no lower than the first, 110.3 then 111.4 for the boys, 117.3 then 124.7 for the girls. The authors do not test that comparison and the break alone could explain the absence of a drop: a single, limited study in favour, so reported.
  6. 2022 Reported A half-by-half reading of the score beside a measure of fatigue, in a single case: a Malaysian university archer shoots seventy-two arrows at thirty metres, electromyography of the bow arm and shoulder shows fatigue building, and the second half closes on 318 points against 307. Within each set the lowest ends come towards the finish, by a few points and without any test. It points the same way as the study of children, and the status stays reported.
  7. 2024 Reported The first real competition arrives: at the 2023 Arab Championships half of the 42 archers score less in the second 70 m half than in the first, with drops of 1 to 18 points among both the leaders and the tail of the rankings, and the other half do not, including three Egyptians out of four who improve. The drop is not systematic, but the table is read without a test, in a regional journal and from a single competition, and it does not separate fatigue from the change in light and wind: the evidence stays limited and the status does not rise.
  8. 2026 Reported Two studies of competitive archers arrive and point the same way. In a Brazilian crossover on a simulated 60-arrow indoor round the two halves give close averages, 218.8 and 216.0 points, while self-reported fatigue climbs from 2 to 3.8 and then to 5.8 out of ten; the study does not test that comparison, though, because its p values compare the social-media condition with the control condition. In a Turkish university group the score does not change from the first to the last of ten ends. The evidence points the claim's way, but the samples are small, the rounds simulated and short, and nearly every comparison of the halves, the only real competition included, is read without a test: it stays limited.

Related

Related articles

Research lines

Studies describe groups of archers, and your own numbers show how far the finding applies to your shooting.

See the programme
Cite
APA

Campagna, M. (2026). Scores do not fall in the second half of a competition, even though fatigue builds up (Version 3). In Evidence Registry. Retrieved 16 October 2026, from https://matteocampagna.com/en/registry/competition/fatigue-second-half-score

BibTeX
@misc{campagna2026_stanchezzafinegarapunteggio,
  author = {Campagna, Matteo},
  title = {Scores do not fall in the second half of a competition, even though fatigue builds up},
  year = {2026},
  howpublished = {Evidence Registry, matteocampagna.com},
  url = {https://matteocampagna.com/en/registry/competition/fatigue-second-half-score},
  note = {Version 3; accessed 2026-10-16}
}

Other claims in this domain

See all claims on competition and scoring